Years ago I heard a story that impressed me so deeply at the time, I’ve never forgotten it. It goes something like this:
Lt. John Blanchard was a young soldier stationed at an Army Base in Florida during the first part of WWII. One day he was reading through a book he had borrowed from the Base Library. He was impressed with some of the notes written in the margin. They were written in feminine handwriting and they were so tender and so thought provoking that he looked back at the fly-leaf to see who had been the previous owner of the book. He found it was a woman named Hollis Maynell.
Blanchard did some research and found her address in New York. He wrote her a letter telling her how much he appreciated her insights in the book. The next day he was shipped overseas but for the next thirteen months, John Blanchard and Hollis Maynell corresponded back and forth. They developed a tremendous relationship through their correspondence and found they had much in common and they thought very much alike.
They began to realize they were falling in love with each other though they had never met. Blanchard asked Hollis Maynell if she would send a picture but she refused. She wrote, “if you really care about me, it wouldn’t matter what I look like because it’s character and what’s inside that really counts.”
After thirteen months the day finally came when he was to meet her. They made arrangements to meet at Grand Central Station in New York City at 7:00 p.m. on a particular night. She said, “you’ll be able to identify me by the red rose I’ll be wearing in my lapel.”
Lt. Blanchard waited with anticipation. Finally, a group of people got off a train and were coming toward him. Out in front was a slender, blond woman with great poise and beauty. She came in a pale green dress that looked like the freshness of Spring and his heart leaped out of his chest as he started toward her.
Then he saw that she did not have a red rose in her lapel even though she was looking directly at him. As she went by with a provocative smile she said, “going my way, soldier?”
Suddenly, he felt a strong desire to follow her but then right behind her he saw Hollis Maynell. She was over forty years of age, had graying hair and was vastly overweight but she was wearing a rose in the lapel of her wrinkled coat. She had gray eyes and a kindly expression but he was so disappointed.
Everything within him wanted to chase after the beautiful blond who was now disappearing. But then he remembered the relationship he developed through those letters and even though this probably wouldn’t develop into marriage, he realized maybe it would develop into something very meaningful, a friendship, a companionship perhaps that he had not known before.
So, without hesitation, he handed her the book which identified him to her and reached for her bag and said, “Are you ready to go to dinner?”
“Young man, I don’t know what this is all about,” she said, “but that blond woman begged me to put on this red rose and she said if you asked me out to eat with you I should tell you that you were suppose to meet her in the restaurant across the street. She said it was some kind of test.”
Lt. John Blanchard passed the test. Would we?